There are many things you can do to avoid failing as a manager.
You can set clear expectations. You can highlight the underlying
purpose of people's work. You can correct people when they do
something wrong. And you can praise people when they do something
right. If you do all these things often and well, you will not fail
as a manager.
However, neither will you necessarily succeed. To excel as a
manager, to turn your people's talents into productive powerful
strengths, requires an additional, all-important ingredient.
Lacking this ingredient, no matter how diligently you set
expectations, communicate purpose, correct mistakes, or praise good
performance, you will never reach excellence. The all-important
ingredient is Individualization, and this is what it sounds
like:
Ralph Gonzalez works as store manager for Best Buy, the
phenomenally successful consumer electronic retailer. A couple of
years ago he was charged with resurrecting a troubled store in
Hialeah, Florida, and with his passion, his creativity, and his
slightly disconcerting resemblance to a youthful Fidel Castro, he
made an immediate impression. To give his people an identity and a
purpose he named his store The Revolution and dubbed each one of
them a revolutionary (a particularly daring decision given the
anti-Castro sentiment in south Florida, and yet it worked). He
drafted a Declaration of Revolution and required that certain
project teams wear army fatigues. He posted all the relevant
performance numbers in the break room and deliberately
overcelebrated every small improvement. And to drive home the point
that excellence is everywhere, he gave all employees a whistle and
told them to blow it loudly whenever they saw any employee or
supervisor or manager do something "revolutionary." Today the
whistles come so frequently that they drown out the Bob Marley CD
playing over the loudspeakers, and the store's numbers confirm the
whistling: No matter which number one uses -- sales growth, profit
growth, customer satisfaction, or employee retention -- the Hialeah
store is one of Best Buy's best.
But, surprisingly, when interviewed, Ralph didn't attribute his
success to The Revolution, to the whistles, or even to his likeness
to a young Castro. Instead, he said this: "Everything comes down to
knowing your people. I always start by asking each new employee,
'Are you a people person or a box person?' In other words, is this
person drawn to strike up a conversation with our customers, or
does he love arranging the merchandise so that each product looks
as if it's about to jump off the shelf? If he is a people person, I
will keep watching to see whether he is just a natural smiler, in
which case I'll probably put him on a checkout register or in
customer service, or whether he also has the talent to sell, in
which case I'll set him up to give multiple presentations of our
newer, more complicated products during our busiest times. And then
I'll watch to see how he likes to be managed. Right now I have a
merchandise manager who needs me to be firm and challenging; he's
that kind of guy, and he expects the same from me. But I also have
an inventory manager who needs something very different from me. He
wants me to explain myself very clearly and to talk about exactly
why we need to do something. I keep watching like this, getting to
know each of them. If I didn't, none of the other stuff would
work."
Ralph Gonzalez, toiling away in relative obscurity in south
Florida, is only one of the great managers who have founded their
approach on the concept of individualization. During our interviews
we discovered tens of thousands like him in factories, sales
departments, hospital wards, and boardrooms. In fact, no matter
where we looked, no matter how anonymous or glamorous the
environment, when we studied great managers, they all seemed to
share this passion for individualization.
When Sam Mendes, the young Oscar-winning director of the film
"American Beauty," was asked by the British newspaper The
Independent to describe the secret of his success, he said, "I am
not a master-class director. I am not a teacher. I am a coach. I
don't have a methodology. Each actor is different. And on the film
set you have to be next to them all, touching them on the shoulder,
saying, 'I'm with you. I know exactly how you're working.' . . .
Kevin Spacey likes to joke and . . . do impersonations right up to
the moment of action, on his mobile phone to his agent or whatever.
The more relaxed, the more jovial he is, the more he's not thinking
about what he does. When you say, 'Action,' he's like a laser beam.
His relaxation leads to spontaneity. So to Kevin you're saying,
'Give me a Walter Matthau impersonation.' Annette Bening, on the
other hand, is on her Walkman half an hour before the cameras roll,
cutting off the set, focused down, listening to the music that the
character would listen to. . . . All I know is that I operate by
going out to each of them and trying to learn the territory in
which they operate." He summed up: "My language to each of them has
to suit their brain."
When Phil Jackson, the coach of the six-time NBA
championship-winning Chicago Bulls, went to the L.A. Lakers, he
brought with him all of the techniques that had served him so well
in Chicago, the Zen philosophy, the meditation sessions, the
triangle offensive system. But he also brought books -- a different
book, it turned out, for each player. To the young superstar Kobe
Bryant he gave a copy of "The White Boy Shuffle" by Paul Beatty
because he felt that the story -- of a black boy raised in a
predominantly white community -- reflected the challenges of Kobe's
own upbringing in suburban Philadelphia. To Shaquille O'Neal, one
of the most recognized and celebrated basketball players in the
world, he chose Friedrich Nietzsche's autobiography "Ecce Homo"
because it dealt with the subject of a man's search for identity,
prestige, and power. Rick Fox, who is said to have aspirations as
an actor, received a copy of the noted Hollywood director Elia
Kazan's autobiography.
Why select different books for each player? According to
Jackson, "The books are to show that I appreciate them and am
focused on who they are."
In your role as manager you have the same opportunity. You will
need to focus on who each employee is. You will need to learn each
one's behavior and, as Sam Mendes did, find the right language "to
suit their brain." The expectations you set will be slightly
different for each person. The way you set them will also be
different for each, as will the way you talk about your company's
mission, the way you correct a mistake, the way you nurture a
strength, and the way you praise, what you praise, and why. All
your moves as a manager will need to be tailored to each individual
employee.
Donald O. Clifton, Ph.D. (1924-2003), was cited as the "Father of Strengths-Based Psychology" in an American Psychological Association Presidential Commendation in 2002. He was a chairman of Gallup, Inc., and he invented the Clifton StrengthsFinder, an assessment that has helped millions of people around the world discover their talents.